On this page: Which onion is which · Seed vs sets vs regrow chart · How many cuttings · Containers and spacing · Succession sowing · Harvest and storage · Pests
Scallions, bunching onions and green onions: which is which
The names overlap. Minnesota uses scallions, bunching onions and green onions for one plant, Allium fistulosum, with green and white stalks and no bulb (UMN). Iowa State says any onion grown mainly for its green tops may be called a bunching onion or scallion (Iowa State, The Other Onions), and UC Master Gardeners add that store "green onions" are usually young bulbing onions pulled before a bulb forms (UC Master Gardeners).
| Plant | Species | Bulb? | Grown as |
|---|---|---|---|
| Welsh or Japanese bunching onion | Allium fistulosum | No; true scallions have no bulb (Illinois) | Annual, or a perennial clump that can be dug and divided (UC Master Gardeners) |
| Young bulbing onion | Allium cepa | Pulled before a bulb forms, or as a spring onion with a 1–2 in bulb (Illinois) | From seed, sets or transplants, picked young (Iowa State) |
| Egyptian walking onion | Allium × proliferum (Iowa State); A. cepa var. proliferum (UMN) | Bulbs below ground and marble-sized bulbils on top | Perennial that spreads as the top bulbils root (Iowa State, UMN) |
| Chives | Allium schoenoprasum | No | Perennial herb (Iowa State) |
Green onion growing chart: seed vs sets vs regrowing roots
| Start from | How to plant | Spacing | First harvest | After the first harvest |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Seed, sown outdoors | As soon as the soil can be worked (UMN, Iowa State), at a soil temperature of at least 50°F (Oregon State); ¼–½ in deep (UMN, UMD, Utah State) or ½–¾ in (Iowa State) | A 2-in-wide band thinned to 1 plant per inch (UMN); 2 in (UMD); 3–4 in, or closer and thinned as you use them (Utah State) | As early as 50 days after seeding (Utah State); about 60–80 days after planting (UC Master Gardeners). Seed emerges in 2–3 weeks (Utah State) | Thinnings are eaten as green onions (UMD, Utah State); cut leaves regrow several times in a season (Oregon State) |
| Transplants started indoors | Sow indoors 4 weeks ahead (UMN), about 5 weeks (UC Master Gardeners), 8 weeks (UMD) or 8–10 weeks (Iowa State, Oregon State); trim roots to ½ in and tops to 4 in (UMN) | 1 in apart in a 2-in-deep furrow (UMN); set 1–1½ in deep (Iowa State) | Typically about 4–6 weeks after planting (Iowa State) | Pulled whole when usable (UMN) |
| Onion sets | Pointed end up (UMD), 1–1½ in deep (Iowa State; 1½ in for large sets, Illinois). Use the larger sets for green onions: bigger than a penny (Iowa State) or a dime (Illinois) | Close enough to touch (Illinois); about 1 in (Iowa State) | When tops are about 6 in tall (Illinois, UMD); typically 4–6 weeks after planting (Iowa State) | Each set makes one onion (Utah State); pull every other plant and let the rest grow on (Illinois, Iowa State) |
| Store-bought root ends | Keep the white base with roots; stand it in just enough water to cover the roots, in a warm, sunny spot; change the water weekly (Iowa State) | Plant into a container or the garden once shoots reach 4–5 in (Iowa State) | Green shoots in about 1–2 weeks (Iowa State) | Clip shoots as needed; the bulb produces for a few months before its reserves run out (Iowa State) |
| Walking onion topsets | Only from topsets, not seed; point up, 1–2 in deep, straw cover for winter (UMN) | 6 in apart (UMN); 9 in (UMD) | No harvest in the first season (UMN) | From the second season, cut greens like chives; new leaves regrow (UMN) |
The set advice pulls two ways. Illinois and Iowa State steer the larger sets to green onions, while Utah State notes that sets over ⅝ in across bolt more readily, and Illinois says large sets may bolt too. Bolted plants should be used right away because they do not keep (Illinois).
- 1. Seed: sow ¼–½ in deep (UMN, UMD, Utah State) and thin to about 1 in apart (UMN)
- 2. Onion sets: pointed end up, 1–1½ in deep (Iowa State; 1½ in, Illinois); use the larger sets for green onions
- 3. Store-bought root end: roots just covered with water, water changed weekly; shoots in 1–2 weeks; plant out when shoots are 4–5 in (Iowa State)
- 4. Cut and regrow: cut leaves as needed; they regrow several times in a season (Oregon State)
- 5. Container: at least 6 in deep with drainage holes (Oregon State); NC State: 2 qt and 6 in
- 6. First harvest: shoots from root ends in 1–2 weeks and sets or transplants in about 4–6 weeks (Iowa State); seed from 50 days (Utah State) to 60–80 days (UC Master Gardeners)
How many cuttings can you get?
None of the extension pages checked for this guide gives a number. Oregon State says bunching onion leaves "regrow several times in one growing season" when cut as needed; Iowa State says a store-bought root end keeps producing shoots for a few months before its reserves run out, and calls regrowing scraps a fun project rather than a replacement for buying produce. Pulling a plant ends it: Minnesota's harvest advice for scallions is to pull them, and digging walking onion bulbs keeps the plant from regrowing (UMN). For repeated cutting, leave the white base and roots in place, and move a regrowing root end into soil once its shoots reach 4–5 in (Iowa State).
Container depth and spacing
| Source | Container | Depth | Spacing |
|---|---|---|---|
| NC State (Table 18-1) | At least 2 qt | 6 in | 2–3 in |
| Oregon State | Drainage holes | At least 6 in | At least 1 in between plants |
| Maryland | 1–3 gal (its small class, with radish, spinach and herbs) | 4–6 in | Not given for containers; 2 in in the garden |
| UW–Madison | At least 2 gal | 4–6 in | Not given |
In the ground, published spacings run from 1 in (UMN, Iowa State) to 2–3 in (UC Master Gardeners) and 3–4 in (Utah State), with rows 8–16 in (Utah State), 12–15 in (Iowa State) or 12–18 in apart (UMN). Two quarts is half a gallon, so NC State's minimum is smaller than Maryland's; compare other crops in the vegetable container size chart.
Light: Minnesota says all onions need full sun for best growth, while Maryland says green onions grow with 5 hours of sun a day and reserves full sun (8–10 hours) for bulbing types. See vegetables for shade for a balcony that gets only part-day sun.
Succession sowing and timing
- Every 3–4 weeks: UC Master Gardeners in Santa Clara County suggest starting a small new patch every 3–4 weeks for a steady supply, and list direct seeding or transplanting from March through October there. More on staggering sowings: succession planting.
- Spring and midsummer: Iowa State sows Welsh onions in early spring for a summer harvest; a second sowing in midsummer can be harvested in fall or the following spring.
- Early spring is safe: green onions are hardy and tolerate heavy spring frosts (UMD). Utah State sows seed in late March or early April and plants sets and transplants in April; Iowa State plants from early April to early May.
- Too early can backfire: cold exposure after very early planting can trigger seed stalks (UMD), and fall-planted scallions may survive winter but can bolt when spring warms (UC Master Gardeners).
Work out your own window from frost dates and the planting calendar.
Watering, harvest and storage
- Water weekly. Water thoroughly at least once a week when rain is under 1 in; sandy soil needs it more often. If a trowel shows only 1–2 in of moist soil, keep watering (UMN). Onion roots are shallow, so keep soil evenly moist and mulch (UC Master Gardeners).
- Weed early. Weeds easily outcompete small onions early in the season; later the dense stand suppresses most of them (UMN).
- Harvest by height. Pull green onions once the tops are about 6 in tall (Illinois, UMD; Oregon State starts at 6 in); Illinois picks true scallions at 8–10 in. Flavor gets stronger with age and size (Illinois).
- Loosen, then pull. Loosen the soil with a trowel or fork so the stalk does not snap at the soil line (UMN, Iowa State). In a dense row, pull every other plant (UC Master Gardeners).
- Store briefly. About 1 week in the refrigerator in a plastic bag (Oregon State) or a perforated bag (Illinois); frozen for cooked dishes, use within 4 months (Oregon State).
Pests and problems
| Problem | What sources say |
|---|---|
| Onion maggot | Bores into stems, causing yellowing and wilting (UMN) |
| Rots | Fusarium basal rot, Botrytis neck rot and bacterial soft rot (UMN); white rot (UMD) |
| Allium leafminer | Listed among onion problems by UMD |
| Bolting | Large sets and early cold can trigger flower stalks (Illinois, UMD, Utah State) |
This page gives no pesticide rates. Minnesota says cultural practices help prevent a wide range of diseases and sends gardeners to its plant disease clinic or Ask a Master Gardener for a diagnosis (UMN). Onion-family crops move bed each year in a crop rotation.
Small-space checklist
- Fastest greens: a store-bought root end in water (1–2 weeks), then into soil at 4–5 in.
- Fastest full plants: large sets or transplants, about 4–6 weeks.
- Cheapest supply: seed, ¼–½ in deep, 50–80 days, sown again every 3–4 weeks.
- A pot at least 6 in deep with drainage holes; plants 1–3 in apart.
- Cut leaves to let them regrow; pull plants when you want the white part.
More crop pages: garlic, radishes, lettuce, spinach and cilantro.
Sources
- University of Minnesota Extension — Growing scallions in home gardens (Marissa Schuh and Jill MacKenzie, reviewed 2024)
- Iowa State University Extension and Outreach, Yard and Garden — All About Onions (Aaron Steil, reviewed July 2024)
- Iowa State University Extension and Outreach, Yard and Garden — The Other Onions (Cynthia Haynes, reviewed July 2024)
- Iowa State University Extension and Outreach, Yard and Garden — How to Grow Vegetables from Kitchen Scraps: Avocados, Pineapples, Green Onions and More (Steil, Jauron and Monaghan, reviewed November 2025)
- University of Maryland Extension — Growing Onions in a Home Garden (updated August 2023)
- Utah State University Extension — How to Grow Onions in Your Garden (Dan Drost, 2020)
- University of Illinois Extension — Onion (Home Vegetable Gardening)
- UC Master Gardeners of Santa Clara County (UC ANR) — Green Bunching Onions
- Oregon State University Extension, Food Hero — Gardening Monthly: Bunching Onions (tip sheet, 2021, PDF)
- NC State Extension Gardener Handbook — Chapter 18, Plants Grown in Containers (Table 18-1)
- University of Maryland Extension — Types of Containers for Growing Vegetables
- University of Wisconsin–Madison Extension — Growing Vegetables in Containers
All sources were opened and checked in October 2026. Rules and figures change; confirm with the original before acting.
More in Crops & herbs
- Crops and herbs
Section overview: every page in this section.
- Garlic: when to plant, how deep and how far apart
Fall planting windows by region, hardneck vs softneck, clove depth and spacing, garlic in pots, scapes, harvest, curing and storage.
- Radishes
Days to harvest by source, sowing temperatures, spacing, containers, flea beetles, root maggots and trap-crop use.
- Lettuce
Spring and fall timing, succession sowing, heat and bolting, containers.
- Spinach
Cool-season sowing dates, day length and bolting, containers, overwintering.
- Cilantro
Why it bolts in heat and long days, spring and fall sowing dates, re-sowing every 2–4 weeks, spacing, 1–3 gallon pots, leaf harvest and coriander seed.